… .. Mental Ray for Maya 7.0 Rendertime Hall of Fame .. …

 

 

You may find the test scene here:

http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?t=291650

 

To be add, all results must be post on :

http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?t=291650

 

 

Pseudo

CPU Name

Code Name

Dual

Hyper

RealCPU

Working

L2 cache

RenderTime

 

 

 

Core

Threading

Freq,

Freq,

Kb

Secondes

leif3d

Dual-Opteron 285

Italy

Y

N

2600

2600

1024

200

RaGzMaN

Dual-Opteron 280

Italy

Y

N

2400

2410

1024

206

dressta

Dual-Opteron 285

Italy

Y

N

2400

2400

1024

200

BeaZtiE

Dual-Opteron 270

Italy

Y

N

2000

2338

1024

219

pixel mixer

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

220

zugok

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

222

dann_stubbs

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

224

DizzyJ

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

227

bernardb

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

227

heemz

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

228

ObsidianFX

Dual-G5 970MP

IBM G5

Y

N

2500

2500

1024

229

papalatistudios

Dual-Opteron 275

Italy

Y

N

2200

2200

1024

230

dressta

Dual-Opteron 275

Italy

Y

N

2200

2200

1024

231

delpadre

Dual-Opteron 270

Italy

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

244

CobraX

Dual-Opteron 265

Italy

Y

N

1800

2009

1024

255

2byts

Dual-Opteron 270

Italy

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

257

Mikademius

Dual-Opteron 270

Italy

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

258

sander0105

Dual-Opteron 270

Italy

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

267

CobraX

Dual-Opteron 265

Italy

Y

N

1800

1800

1024

282

Fredrik Averpil

Dual-Opteron 265

Italy

Y

N

1800

1800

1024

283

mustafa

Pentium D 965 EE

Presler

Y

N

3730

4000

2048

370

yinako

Dual-Xeon 3,8

Irwindale

Y

N

3800

3800

2048

375

mar_one

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2553

512

377

mustafa

Pentium D 965 EE

Presler

Y

N

3730

3830

2048

379

Shawin

Athlon X2 3800+

Toledo

Y

N

2000

2600

1024

390

BeaZtiE

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2553

512

400

Koogle

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2553

512

402

papalatistudios

Dual-Xeon 3,0

Prestonia

N

Y

3066

3066

512

402

a3R

Opteron 165

Italy

Y

N

1800

2502

1024

404

blue magic

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2440

512

405

T-h-i-j-s

Dual-Xeon 3,4

Cranford

N

Y

3400

3400

2048

409

T-h-i-j-s

Dual-Xeon 3,4

Cranford

N

Y

3400

3400

1024

412

dan1el

Dual-Xeon 3,4

????

N

Y

3400

3400

????

415

iktome

Opteron 280

Italy

Y

N

2400

2400

1024

417

azshall

Athlon FX 60

Toledo

Y

N

2600

2600

1024

420

Stilgarna

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2400

512

420

tharell

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2420

512

422

Nando3D

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2410

1024

425

Stilgarna

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2400

512

426

enape

Dual-Xeon 3,0

Prestonia

N

Y

3066

3066

512

428

Praedicator

Dual-G5 2,7Ghz

IBM G5

N

N

2700

2700

1024

439

cgtriguy

Dual-G5 2,5Ghz

IBM G5

N

N

2500

2500

1024

441

Kriz

Athlon X2 4800+

Toledo

Y

N

2400

2400

1024

445

cgtriguy

Core-Duo T2600

Yonath

Y

N

2160

2160

1024

446

mimik

Core-Duo T2600

Yonath

Y

N

2160

2160

1024

446

enape

Core-Duo T2600

Yonath

Y

N

2160

2160

1024

448

Marcel

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

449

HamburgerTrain

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2200

512

451

bls

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

453

tharell

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2200

512

453

sl3966

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2300

512

455

mooncry

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

461

alexentremont

Dual-G5 2,5Ghz

IBM G5

N

?

2500

2500

1024

461

Ohlda

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

462

Synthesizer

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2300

512

463

Jadetiger

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2200

1024

465

3rd user

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2200

512

468

Jozvex

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2200

512

474

Sheep Factory

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

474

acidream

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

477

victor

Athlon X2 4400+

Toledo

Y

N

2200

2210

1024

479

Kabab

Core-Duo T2500

Yonath

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

479

FredrikAverpil

Core-Duo T2500

Yonath

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

486

Shawin

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2000

512

487

Steve McRae

Dual-Opteron 248

Hammer

N

N

2200

2192

1024

487

Synthesizer

Athlon X2 4200+

Manchester

Y

N

2200

2200

512

490

SergO

Dual-Opteron 248

Hammer

N

N

2200

2200

1024

489

liudger

Core-Duo T2500

Yonath

Y

N

2000

2000

1024

492

halloween

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2009

512

497

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon 3,0

Prestonia

N

N

3066

3312

512

500

Stilgarna

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2000

512

503

_vive_

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2000

512

504

jwr38

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2000

512

504

mike0006

Athlon X2 3800+

Manchester

Y

N

2000

2000

512

509

Ryan_K

Dual-Opteron 246

Hammer

N

N

2000

2000

1024

514

ultrabook

Dual-Opteron 246

Hammer

N

N

2000

2000

1024

519

DeathBrain

Dual-Xeon 3,6

Nocona

Y

N

3200

3200

1024

526

BeaZtiE

Core-Duo T2300E

Yonath

Y

N

1666

1800

1024

528

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon 3,0

Prestonia

N

N

3066

3400

512

545

Andy Whiteley

Pentium D 950

Presler

Y

N

3400

3400

2048

549

Unschuldiger Zivilist

Dual-G5 2Ghz

IBM G5

N

?

2000

2000

1024

550

djx

Dual-Xeon 3,4

Nocona

Y

N

3400

3400

1024

555

Dialector

Dual-Xeon 3,0

????

N

?

????

????

????

555

a3R

Opteron 165

Italy

Y

N

1800

1800

1024

556

mech7

Athlon64 3500+

Venice

N

N

2300

2300

512

564

azloha

Opteron 165

Italy

Y

N

1800

1800

1024

566

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon 3,0

Prestonia

N

Y

3066

3312

512

567

pixel mixer

Core-Duo T2300

Yonath

Y

N

1666

1666

1024

573

BeaZtiE

Core-Duo T2300

Yonath

Y

N

1666

1666

1024

574

djx

Dual-Xeon 3,2

Nocona

Y

N

3200

3200

1024

587

Stilgarna

Pentium D 820

SmithField

Y

N

2800

3108

1024

601

Sully

Dual-Athlon MP

Thoroughbred

N

N

2000

2000

256

607

kryoboy

Athlon 64 FX-55

SanDiego

N

N

2600

2613

1024

618

Matadŏr

Dual-Athlon MP

Barton

N

N

2000

2000

512

620

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon 3,0

Prestonia

N

Y

3066

3066

512

628

pixel mixer

Pentium D 820

SmithField

Y

N

2800

2800

1024

667

Stilgarna

Pentium D 820

SmithField

Y

N

2800

2800

1024

671

djx

Dual-Xeon 3,2

Nocona

Y

Y

3200

3200

1024

687

sumatra invitro

Dual-G5 1,8Ghz

IBM G5

N

N

????

1800

1024

692

Cageman

Dual-Athlon MP

Thoroughbred

N

N

1800

1800

256

756

Andy Whiteley

Pentium 4 3,4

Northwood

N

Y

3400

3400

512

736

mustafa

Pentium 4 3,0

Northwood

N

Y

3200

3200

512

772

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 560

Prescott

N

Y

3400

3400

1024

832

colt

Athlon 64 3500+

Newcastle

N

N

2300

2365

1024

846

Juha

Pentium 4 3,0

Northwood

N

Y

3066

3000

512

853

annaleah

Pentium 4 540

Prescott

N

Y

3200

3200

1024

867

colt

Athlon 64 3500+

Venice

N

N

2300

2365

512

870

Brent Turbo

Pentium M 770

Dothan

N

N

2130

2130

2048

873

Danoku

Athlon 64 3700+

Newcastle

N

N

2200

2200

1024

891

The Spook

Pentium 4 2,8

Northwood

N

Y

2800

2800

512

912

Rick Flowers

Pentium 4 2,4

Northwood

N

Y

2400

2880

512

913

eodmpink

Athlon 64 3500+

Newcastle

N

N

2300

2400

1024

917

kiaran

Pentium 4 2,8

???

N

Y

2800

2800

???

938

Mr. Positive

Athlon 64 3400+

Newcastle

N

N

2200

2200

1024

944

dagon1978

Athlon XP 2500+

Barton

N

N

1800

2400

512

951

Matadŏr

Pentium M760

Dothan

N

N

2000

2000

2048

958

mustique

Pentium 4 2,8

???

N

Y

2800

2800

???

963

Andy Whiteley

Pentium 4 3,4

Northwood

N

N

3400

3400

512

967

3d_guru

Athlon 64 3000+

Venice

N

N

1800

1800

512

969

ultrabook

Opteron 246

Hammer

N

N

2000

2000

1024

1033

dagon1978

Athlon XP 2500+

Barton

N

N

1800

2200

512

1036

A_New_Hope

Pentium 4 520

Prescott

N

Y

2800

2800

1024

1039

Synthesizer

Athlon XP 2500+

Barton

N

N

1800

2200

512

1072

Bleed

Pentium M755

Dothan

N

N

1800

1800

2048

1082

Cageman

Athlon 64M 3000+

Oakville

N

N

1800

1800

512

1113

colt

Pentium M 735

Dothan

N

N

1700

1700

2048

1115

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 560

Prescott

N

N

3400

3400

1024

1116

enape

Pentium M

Banias

N

N

1700

1700

1024

1139

ty666

Pentium 4 2,8

Northwood

N

Y

2800

2800

512

1155

ultrakyo

Pentium M

Banias

N

N

1700

1700

1024

1165

pixel mixer

Semprom 3100+

 

N

N

1800

1800

256

1172

Shawin

Pentium M 725

Dothan

N

N

1600

1600

2048

1217

dirty

Athlon XP 2400+

Thoroughbred

N

N

2000

2000

256

1234

dagon1978

Athlon XP 2500+

Barton

N

N

1800

1800

512

1244

toto_7

Pentium 4 2,4

Northwood

N

Y

2400

2400

512

1331

DizzyJ

Pentium M 725

Dothan

N

N

1600

1600

2048

1354

rock

Pentium M 725

Dothan

N

N

1600

1600

2048

1437

Jozvex

Athlon XP 1800+

Palomino

N

N

1500

1544

256

1552

ultrakyo

Athlon XP 1900+

Palomino

N

N

1600

1600

256

1918

et_fone_home

Athlon XP 2000+

???

N

N

1000

1000

???

1923

iktome

Powerbook G4

???

N

N

1500

1500

???

2883

 

Thanks for all who plays the game…

 

Results with Mental Ray stand alone are very closed…

 

Strange results are ITALIC

 

 

 

!!!! ONLY FOR SMP !!!!

As we see, for Rendering with Mental Ray and Maya, Hyperthreading must be disable with Dual Processeur (Xeon) or Dual-Core (Pentium D 840EE).

For an every day workflow or workstation I suggest to let the HT enable. For renderfarm turn it OFF.

!!!! ONLY FOR SMP !!!!

 

L2 cache is per core.

 

Northwood & Prestonia are better than Prescott & Nocona…Due to shortest pipeline on Northwood and Prestonia...

 

 

 

Here is an old test’s results for Mental Ray for Maya 6.01

Just for information 

 

 

Pseudo

CPU Name

Code Name

Dual

Hyper

Frequency

L2 cache

Size

RenderTime

 

 

 

Core

Threading

Mhz

Kb

Micron

Secondes

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon

Prestonia

N

Y

3404

512

0,13

280

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon

Prestonia

N

Y

3066

512

0,13

312

Stilgarna

Pentium D 820

SmithField

Y

N

3108

1024

0,09

355

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon

Nocona

N

Y

3400

1024

0,09

356

Stilgarna

Pentium D 820

SmithField

Y

N

2800

1024

0,09

389

Stilgarna

Dual-Xeon

Prestonia

N

Y

2800

512

0,13

390

Stilgarna

Xeon

Prestonia

N

Y

3400

512

0,13

424

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 660

Prescott

N

Y

3600

2048

0,09

440

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 650

Prescott

N

Y

3400

2048

0,09

468

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 550

Prescott

N

Y

3400

1024

0,09

475

Stilgarna

Pentium 4

Northwood

N

Y

3066

512

0,13

487

Stilgarna

Pentium M 760

Dothan

N

Y

2160

2048

0,09

496

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 640

Prescott

N

Y

3200

2048

0,09

499

Stilgarna

Pentium 4 540

Prescott

N

Y

3200

1024

0,09

511

Stilgarna

Athlon XP 3200+

Barton

N

N

2200

512

0,13

600

Stilgarna

Pentium 4

Northwood

N

Y

2666

512

0,13

689

Stilgarna

Pentium 3

Coppermine

N

N

999

256

0,18

840

Stilgarna

Pentium 3

Coppermine

N

N

933

256

0,18

866